please empty your brain below

Reading between the lines, do we take it that nothing has been improved for pedestrians?
I'm not sure how this is ever going to work.

Venera obeyed the lights here and was killed by a truck also obeying the green lights: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/london-cycling-deaths-sister-of-young-entrepreneur-killed-at-bow-roundabout-wants-tragedy-to-be-a-force-for-good-8943132.html

Lana obeyed the lights here and was killed by a truck also obeying the lights: http://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/we-are-shocked-driver-wont-face-court-says-family-of-dead-cyclist-svitlana-tereschenko-7711231.html

Brian obeyed the lights and was killed here by a truck also obeying the lights: http://road.cc/content/news/96460-brian-dorling-inquest-coroner-record-narrative-verdict-bow-roundabout-fatality

If you had to choose between (a) having a truck painfully crush your torso until you expire and (b) waiting for a clear gap in the traffic and carefully jumping a red light, which would you choose?
I thought the whole point of these lights was because drivers were not understanding the "early start" of the cycle phase and so the low level lights were to be more obviously "just for cyclists". (its certainly an issue with the one example we have in Cambridge).

But if that's the case, why on earth have they kept the old normal ones?

"Having two sets of lights is confusing people...I know, we need more lights!"
Staying Alive - I thought that the inquest found that Brian Dorling (and the lorry driver) *both* jumped a red light?

eg http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-24539584
laws unto themselves...still HATE them
Well, anecdotally - I rode CS2 Westbound this morning - and was part of a group of 6 cyclists who all obeyed both lights.

I didn't see any cyclists on the flyover either.

CS2 is horrible though - and semi-lethal when you reach Aldgate. My current commute is CS3 which is much better in every regard. Not looking forward to using CS2 every day once we move...
I'd love to say that's two posts, one for each set of lights - but no, just my fat fingers again… :(
I'm sure they're expecting people to skip the lights - but they will now have evidence that when the inevitable death comes, it's because it's a cyclist ignoring lights, like cyclists do all the time. That's surely what that CCTV is for too, post-fatality arse covering.

Blame shifted. Job done.
No point trying to use facts when cyclists are involved, BW. Heads in the sand (or somewhere else) the lot of them.

> "somewhere that bad behaviour hadn't already set in"

Good luck finding that place - the cyclists' contempt for the rules of the road, not to mention good manners, is endemic.
Ha, Simon, I'll raise you with my own #futilecommentontheinternet

The blinkeredness of those that moan about cyclists' behaviour towards the death and serious injury caused by motorists' contempt for the rules of the road, not to mention good manners, is endemic.
To be fair, when a percentage of cyclists don't obey the rules, how can you engineer anything in to make it safer?

If the lights are obeyed, then you should be safe at Bow now.
Re Anon - "To be fair, when a percentage of cyclists don't obey the rules, how can you engineer anything in to make it safer?"

It's got nothing to do with cyclists not obeying the rules - motorists don't obey the rules - people don't obey the rules.

You aim to engineer out the danger. Look at the work of Dutch and Danish engineers to answer your question. They've been doing it pretty well for decades.

You give all users of the junction, that's including pedestrians, at least equal status and you start from there. A rather different design, layout and filtering system will then be reached - far removed from the attempted shoe-horning in of a cycle facility into a design still ultimately dominated by precious motor traffic flow requirements.

- "If the lights are obeyed, then you should be safe at Bow now."

Hmmm, me thinks you haven't cycled across Bow roundabout with this current lights system in place to experience your perceived cosy feeling of safety...

Cycling across Bow roundabout is no safer than before the cycle superhighway was installed two and a half years ago. Three deaths since then illustrate that.
Hmmm. '... either fail to understand or choose to ignore...'
That'd largely be 'choose to ignore' then.
Seems like trying to get cyclists to observe signals is like trying to herd cats.
There does, however, seem to be a crucial difference.
Cats might have nine lives. Cyclists would be well advised that they don't.
unfortunately, some cyclists take risks or endanger others, then this gives all cyclists a bad name. I cycled in London for 30 years, never on the pavement, never through red lights. I had a few narrow escapes and minor injuries, mainly caused by pedestrians stepping in front of me or car doors opening on me. I'm glad I don't have to cycle round the Bow roundabout any more, but if I did, I'd probably get off and walk round.
Not entirely unsurprising result. Many cyclists feel safer dodging through traffic. Not really sure what the answer is - perhaps proper cycle lanes etc.
1)
Build proper segregated cycle lanes across London. Cost - hundreds of millions, result - massive reduction in serious injuries and deaths, happier cyclists AND happier drivers because less bicycles slowing them down. Peace governs.

Or

2)
Spend a few thousand on some funky cyclist lights at a handful of news-worthy junctions. Phew, that was cheap. Utilise journalists loyal to the Tory-cause to frame the media debate in terms of cyclist wearing lycra/jumping lights/victim blaming. Stoke anger and tension between road users to divide them, ensuring no serious money gets spent. Result - deaths and serious injuries remain, society dispupted with road-users manipulated into fighting eachother with mis-placed anger. Sit-back and count the Tory coffers to determine how big that tax-cut to the rich will be. This is what Boris has done over his six years, with his 'its all going to get better, just around the corner, i promise' politics.

You decide which option you want by voting at the next election.
I guess I don't have nine lives, but since the CS2 extension to Stratford, I wish I did.

Westbound in the morning, dark for six months of the year... the transition from the poky narrow cycle lanes with their stupid sharp raised concrete kerbs to the flyover (my preferred route for many years, thanks very much) is now really, really dangerous. It is only a matter of time before some driver flattens a cyclist. Hopefully not me, but it has already nearly happened several times.

Eastbound, it is late at night, I have had a long busy day, and I am using the flyover - again, my preferred route, along with at least 75% of other cyclists. I come off the flyover and am immediately intimidated by the left side flow of traffic coming straight into my path. How do I get into the segregated cycle lane? Panic panic. The first break in the stupid segregated kerb is almost impossible to manoeuvre into …. the next one? AAAArghh… I only just get in there…so far.

What is this junction designed for?
As Amber has said, I do think the only sensible and blaringly obvious thing that needs to be done for the time being is making it compulsory for cyclists dismount (with barriers if need be) at the roundabout and walk alongside pedestrians (in both directions). Sorry cyclists - think it's better to be alive!

Having recently seen how ineffective these confusing lights are (the first set turn green, the second set which are still red are forgotten about and cyclists go on, despite oncoming traffic coming around onto the slip roads!!).

It would also help the welfare of pedestrians who additionally have to dice death due to no ped light crossings which need to be installed and can be jointly used by pedestrians and cyclists. It's also the cheapest option until it is financially viable to create segregated cycle and ped lanes over the bow deathabout.

No doubt this has been suggested before, I can't see why it can't be done!
I think DG has mentioned elsewhere that the busy roundabout in Chiswick, where the A4/M4 flyover crosses the North Circular Road, has traffic light controlled pedestrian/cycle crossings that go onto the large central area of the roundabout, where nicely landscaped and lit paths go to whichever exit you're aiming for. Even though this involves stopping traffic, it seems to work well enough. While they're in such an experimental mood, they could at least try something like this at Bow.










TridentScan | Privacy Policy