please empty your brain below

I examined the sparkly new slimline ticket machine on the platform at Emerson Park recently (a one platform Overground station on the single track Romford-Upminster branch which has never had a ticket office and is currently being 'improved' with various TfL type features).
It's an impressive machine - very easy and intuitive to use, allowing tickets to be purchased from any National Rail/Overground station to any National Rail/Overground station and including the full National Rail range of Rovers and Rangers - even the 14 day Furst Class All Line Rover at £1,138 can be purchased!
This, of course, is a requirement of all ticket offices on National Rail.
Technically, Overground stations should be part of the National Rail network, which means if there is a ticket office you can collect advance purchase tickets, book a return to Thurso, in advance if you want, and book tickets to and from another station, rather than the one you are at. Hope the new ticket machines can offer all that functionality. The difference in philosophies is the Overground station ticket offices have to know that the rest of the UK exists.
Can these swanky new machines do railcards though?! Or season tickets that require photocard (as some do)
It seems they can!

Now, let's drag the Underground screaming and kicking into the 21st century and integrate their ticketing properly with National Rail. It's ridiculous that I can book an overnight return to Great Missenden but not Amersham
I assume Willesden Junction is operated by the London Overground concessionaire.

These tube line ticket offices, operated by LU, are at National Rail stations. This meant they are protected by schedule 17 of the National Rail ticketing and settlement agreement, and so TfL could not close them off its own bat but rather requires the consent of London Travelwatch or the Secretary of State.

Note that the remaining stations are served by London Midland or Southern which probably explains their ticket offices being retained for the time being. People with complicated trips are much more likely to use these then Kew Gardens etc.
Finsbury Park - wasn't it the ticket office at the Wells Terrace entrance that closed, it's the Station Place one that remains open.

I thought Harrow & Wealdstone also had two ticket offices, the map shows two, do they both shut, or is the other run by London Midland (or whatever its called)?

http://www.nationalrail.co.uk/stations-and-destinations/stations-made-easy/harrow-and-wealdstone-station-plan

This is the large version - so you'll have to slide the image about.
Post updated with your additional info about National Rail ticketing and the enhanced functionality of the new ticket machines, thanks.
I’m curious as to how stations get designated as Overground vs Underground stations, where they serve both. For instance Highbury & Islington is an Underground station, despite serving two different Overground lines plus one National Rail line and only one Underground line. So it has no ticket office.
There is currently a proposal to close all ticket offices on the Overground, expect this to go through by the end of next year.
All stations are leased and run by a single Train Operating Company or by Network Rail. So Willesden Junction is run by the Overground, Wimbledon by South Western Railway etc. National Rail does not run anything on the ground.

You have overlooked another ticket office on the Underground - Terminal 5 has one and this is run by Heathrow Express.

It is possible that you will see the odd member of Underground staff at stations run by another company.
Stratford is another interesting example it retains two ticket offices run by TfL Rail one if which is in one of the Underground ticket halls!
Post updated again, thanks.
Absolutely fascinating! It makes the days of the original nineteenth century competing railway companies seem positively straightforward, but then 'competition' was what the Tories wanted from their privatisations. They've certainly got it, they probably just weren't expecting different parts of TfL to be in competition with each other.

Nice touch how at Gunnersbury the staff 'was stood/sat' whereas the staff at Kew Gardens are grammatically correct. These are the touches we love about DG.
I suspect Willesden Junction remaining open may be related to HS2 at Old Oak Common.
Whenever I went through Gunnersbury, there was always a member of staff by the barrier and one behind the glass anyway, so it seems as though little has changed.
How many Overground stations are there? 65?

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/transport/safety-row-over-plans-to-axe-ticket-offices-at-65-london-overground-stations-a3635496.html
"How many Overground stations are there? "

From a quick count from the map, there are about 111 stations served by Overground services, but many of these stations are managed by other operators such as TfL Rail, the Underground, C2C, Anglia, London Midland, SWR, Southern, South Eastern, and Network Rail.
For a time, I booked tickets online using the Southern website. Then they unveiled ticket office closure plans and I went back to using ticket offices on the basis of 'Use them or lose them'(same as using manned checkouts at the supermarket).

Do the new ticket machines have 'Boundary Of Zone 6' as a starting point for journeys outside the London zones? It can be cheaper for many journeys if you have a London travel pass such as a Freedom.
Your revision re Willesden Junction is incorrect! It is not a tube station but an Overground station with a tube service as well.

dg writes: For the purposes of this post, all 270 stations with tube services are tube stations.
Being as HM The Queen Elizabeth II's Crossrail Line One is going to be considered part of the National Rail network, does this mean that the enhanced ticket machines will start appearing at Bond Street, TCR etc?

(The track doesn't have to be owned by Network Rail to be part of the National Rail network; exactly the same thing happens with the East London line whose track is also owned by TfL.)
Tottenham Hale has a ticket office too... as part of the NR bit, so I'm not sure if it counts...

dg writes: TfL closed their ticket office here, and it was on a separate gateline, so I decided 'no'.
Geoff,

Yes, I was told that enhanced ticket machines will appear at Bond St etc. Which then begs the question, why not put them at all London Underground stations?

More interesting is how far they will go out. From the artist's drawings it doesn't look as if Custom House will have a ticket office. I suspect Woolwich won't either but we do know that currently Abbey Wood has one - and a new one at that.

It is going to seem a bit irrational if some of the quieter TfL-managed Crossrail stations have a ticket office but busy London Overground ones don't. Acton Main Line and Hanwell are not busy stations.
As stated Willesden Junction is run by Arriva under the terms of their concession contract for London Overground services. They are bound by the terms applicable to the retailing of National Rail tickets.

The issues surrounding National Rail ticketing and the extent of the product range / stations retailed have been troublesome for LU / LT / TfL for decades. The London passengers watchdog (under many different names) has never shifted in its view that the range should never be reduced if there is a change of operating business. I am actually surprised that some station ticket offices have actually been closed down given London Travelwatch's position. I can only assume the Secretary of State is happy to see cost savings rather than customer service.

For all the wonders of new fangled ticket machines I can guarantee there is one form of product they don't handle - privilege fares for rail staff. Only ticket offices can retail these and shutting down what are actually National Rail station facilities deprives people of access to these products. TfL wiping out ticket offices from the Overground will deal a serious blow to the retailing of these tickets. OK it is a minority product in the greater scheme of things but even so. I imagine the same nonsense will prevail on much of Crossrail despite its important role in linking up disparate parts of the National Rail network.
The new Overground TVMs need better software. If you ask for Charing Cross they will happily sell you a ticket to the station of that name in Glasgow but fail to mention the one in London.

You have to ask for London Charing Cross, but only anoraks will know that.
As already mentioned, Willesden Junction is run by the London Overground concession - as-is Kensington Olympia so that explains that one.
@gerry

I would expect a similar problem with Waterloo (Merseyside)
Hornchurch is a great example of removing the ticket office, putting a glass screen where a member of staff sits behind and the staff do even less, sometimes the glass screen is shut even though people are inside.

You hardly see them out on the station concourse except if there is an issue, even though there are 3 people milling around.

This isn't a rant, but 'operation do nothing' is a good description of a lot of tube station staff.. a cushy number
Do TfL have any plans to close the DLR's solitary ticket office?
The last two or three times I've wanted to get a ticket from Harrow & Wealdstone, the machines have been faulty, not able to process bank card transactions.
Max -
You don't need to buy an overnight return to Amersham, you can just use pay as you go, something you can't do to to Great Missenden.

Paul -
Don't worry about the lack of Priv tickets from machines. At worst it means you have to buy a ticket later in the journey "at the first available opportunity" but often it means a free ride!
Andrew S - not if you live outside London! Max lives rather a long way past Z9 in Essex.

While he can use PAYG from Stratford or Liverpool Street, he would need to buy a ticket to there and then use PAYG. Effectively it is buying two different tickets. Max's complaint is the lack of integration that exists one stop further out.

It was always a bugbear of mine when travelling occasionally from Southampton to Amersham by train. I could buy a ticket to Great Missenden, I could buy a ticket with a Z1-6 Travelcard, I could not buy a ticket to Amersham (despite NR serving the station) nor Z9.

And the problem that way around (to Amersham) is less of an issue than the other way around - NR ticket machines can get you to all stations served by NR save 4, and all stations served by LU save 6. LU ticket machines can get you to places with Oyster PAYG, and occasionally somewhere else (eg Amersham sells tickets to Great Missenden as if it didn't, that would be truly insane).
"Oystery" - a lovely word. Beats the "cupboardy" from Little Britain!
@ Andrew S - I am aware of the rules but I object to having to faff around pressing multiple buttons to find something like the right fare rather than being able to buy the right ticket from a ticket office.

It only takes 1 encounter with an officious ticket inspector or guard who doesn't believe you and your privilege ticket facility may be withdrawn on the grounds of "misuse". There are enough horror stories as to how people on advance tickets are treated to make this is a viable concern. It isn't worth taking the risk (in my view).
@S What are the 4 NR stations you can’t buy a ticket to? Are these the likes of Norton Bridge and Newhaven Marine?
I'm confused by the discussion above, Off peak returns Southampton-Amersham are available: http://www.brfares.com/#!fares?orig=SOU&dest=AMR

I also have fond memories of buying an off-peak return to Epsom from the LUL ticket machine at West Brompton, and getting some very confused looks from the gateline staff there. I'd assume that other LUL-owned NR station ticket machines still have the facility to issue NR tickets.
Apparently, despite what I thought at the time...

"The ticket office at Kew Gardens will close from Saturday 2 December 2017. The ticket office at Gunnersbury will be closed from Saturday 23 December 2017."
It would appear that all the Bakerloo line ticket offices have now closed, except for Willesden Junction (as noted) and, oddly enough, Harlesden. It seems like they've been having issues with the only installed ticket machine there.










TridentScan | Privacy Policy